New study: Which beverages burst with umami potential?
In a new and first of its kind study, University of Copenhagen researchers study fermented beverages to find the one with the most umami flavour. Which one wins—champagne, beer, wine or sake? A UCPH researcher answers below.
A fifth basic flavour has crept into our conceptualisation of foods in recent years—umami. In Japanese, umami translates roughly to ‘savoury deliciousness’. It is often associated with the earthy flavours of meat, mushrooms, broths and vine-ripened tomatoes. It enhances saltiness and sweetness, while reducing bitterness, which is why most people love it.
But does umami exist in beverages? And if so, which fermented beverage has the most umami potential: wine, beer, sake or champagne? And, what happens to flavours when these beverages are paired with foods? Three researchers from the University of Copenhagen’s Department of Food Science have published this first of a kind study in the journal Food Chemistry.
"We investigated the average umami flavour content in a range of wines, champagnes, beers and sakes. Our analyses demonstrate that it is in sake (Japanese rice wine), where umami reigns supreme on the umami scale, far ahead of beer, followed by champagne and finally wine. However, we studied slightly fewer beers than the other beverages, so that class of beverage may have been difficult to score precisely," reports postdoctoral researcher Charlotte Vinther Schmidt, one of the study’s authors.
Higher potential when paired with food
Determining the umami flavour content of a drink involves finding out how much of an amino acid known as glutamic acid there is in it. Umami flavour reaches us by way of glutamate as it lands on the specialised "umami" taste receptors of our tongues.
"Our results suggest that the longer a beverage’s fermentation time, the higher its glutamate content—which leads to more umami flavour. This is probably why sake leads the pack by so much in terms of umami, as it is typically fermented using both yeast and a mold culture called koji," explains Charlotte Vinther Schmidt.
But even if other beverages can’t match sake’s umami flavor on their own, UCPH’s savoury-deliciousness experts assert that the flavour can be provoked by pairing.
"We already know about food combinations which pair happily—like ham and cheese, for example. Therefore, we calculated the effects of pairing shellfish like oysters, shrimp and scallops with the various beverages, so as to investigate which combinations would synergize and provoke an emergence of umami. Here, we conclude that each of the beverage classes studied elicit an umami flavour when paired with oysters and tuna. Furthermore, sake, certain aged wines and champagne can also exhibit umami flavour when paired with scallops," explains CharlotteVinther Schmidt.
According to the researchers, this is because pairing high-content glutamate drinks with foods high in ribonucleotides (RNA's building blocks), catalyzes a synergistic flavour magic through which the best qualities of both drink and food emerge.
"If one takes a drink with glutamate and a food with just as many ribonucleotides, the umami flavour can generally be multiplied by eight," explains Charlotte Vinther Schmidt.
Useful knowledge for sustainable eating
Knowing how to enhance umami is useful when it comes to a more sustainable diet, as Charlotte Vinther Schmidt explains:
"If we can understand which vegetables, that together with selected beverages, provide the best taste—that umami contributes to—we could probably get far more people to consume vegetables, which is healthy for us humans, as well as for our planet."
So, there is good reason to consider the rapport between a meal’s food and drink, as Charlotte Vinther Schmidt concludes:
"Although there are other factors contribute to taste experiences, like mouthfeel and smell, it might be a good idea to buy beverages with a high concentration of umami, as they improve the chance of enhancing taste in high-ribonucleotide foods, thus resulting in the delightful savoury-deliciousness of umami."
Average umami flavour content in selected beverages:
The researchers studied 8 sakes, 9 types of white, rosé and sparkling wines, 9 champagnes and 5 types of beer. Here is the average umami content for each beverage class:
- Sake = 20,1
- Beer = 5,7
- Champagne = 4,2
- Wines = 3.5
Umami potential in beer:
The researchers selected a number of beers and studied their glutamate content, and in doing so, their umami flavour. These are the beers with the most and least umami flavour (1 is most, 5 least) measured in milligrams of glutamate per 100 milliliters of liquid.
- Grimbergen (8.4)
- Carlsberg (8.2)
- Fynsk Forår (6.2)
- Paulaner Hefe-Weisse (2,8)
- Bavaria Wit (2.7)